My Airbnb Biz Got Me Evicted, Here's What I Learned

It only took five years for the couch-surfing startup Airbnb to rocket past 10 million bookings—and it only took 10 days for my landlord to force me out of my apartment for riding the wave.

After court appearances, phone calls, and printer cartidges, the ink is dry on a settlement that has me vacating my apartment in 10 days, all because I turned to Airbnb instead of Craigslist to find roommates—and a chunk of income in the process. Given that Airbnb announced today that it had surpassed 10 million bookings, I'm hardly alone in my thinking. Nevertheless, here's what I learned from being pushed out of my apartment for being an Airbnb host.

Go Big Or Go Home

None of my landlord's complaints had anything to do with how frequently I hosted, or even how much money I was making. Nor did the fact that I lived in the apartment with my guests mitigate his outrage. In fact, his counsel’s biggest point of contention was that I hadn’t sought permission for any of these roommates, something my lease requires me to do.

If you do get permission and plunge in, don’t half-ass it. Like an online dating site, your listing floats to the top of search as you become more active on the site, which in turn boosts your visibility to guests. Bringing in more reservation requests makes it easier to find guests that fit, which is more important than you’d think; I quickly learned, for example, that I couldn’t book couples for weekend stays, because they resented my building’s late-night party noise. (Lone guests stayed out later with friends, or went to join the ruckus.) 

Imagine The Misinterpretations

Imagine your landlord or neighbors have no idea what Airbnb does or how it works—then imagine they find your listing. How would it come off? My landlord thought I was running an actual bed-and-breakfast business, and suspected I was making far more money than I actually was. In fact I was using Airbnb to find short-term roommates, in lieu of using Craigslist, where anonymity and bad UI make this a huge hassle. To him, my little scheme looked too much like ... a big scheme. (Check out the sidebar to see my actual profit and loss by the numbers.)

Have An Explanation

My landlord never contacted me before I was served with a restraining order. If he had, I would have explained that an actual "bed and breakfast" serves you food, does your laundry, and cleans your room—all things I didn’t do as a host since I never would have as a roommate. Airbnb gives you payment infrastructure and protection that Craigslist doesn’t, but if you don’t have a succinct way of explaining that to nosy landlords and curious neighbors, then you should. If you’re new at Airbnb, approach the relevant people and explain your rationale before you dive in and become a super-host.

Get To Know Other Hosts

Other tentants in my building were pushed out for Airbnb hosting before I was, but I didn't find out until it was too late. Still, that's the least of the reasons to go to Airbnb meetups; attending them can teach you invaluable lessons about your own hospitality skills. Spitballing about prices, mishaps, and weird guests with other hosts in Greenpoint, I began to get a sense of how my apartment's vibe appeared to strangers, which let me rarify my listing and fix things that came off as unappealing. Since Airbnb properties can be so unique, referrals are vital, and learning where you fit in your niche helps you really harness all that social commerce to get more (and more interesting) guests.

Be Sincere

In his legal action, my landlord complained about the sundry "security risks" my guests posed to other tenants. I never learned how my landlord found my Airbnb listing, but the frequency of luggage-wielding European tourists getting lost in the halls was probably a tip-off that something was afoot. If you're worried about attracting heat, pick guests you'd choose as roommates—they won’t seem (or, for that matter, feel) wildly out of place as any old tourist. Because new guests require various levels of ice-breaking and orientation, I eventually sought to book repeat guests who I already knew and liked. Unless you’re in it for the money, think of Airbnb guests as a rotating cast of roommates and less like a series of profitable one-night stands.

Be Careful When You Add Value

I thought I’d earn more business by making my place look as fly as possible, and Airbnb’s pro photographers made sure my listing shone. In retrospect, I probably also succeeded in convincing my landlord he had undervalued my place by a huge margin, which I was now apparently taking. In growing cities like Brooklyn, prudent landlords like to turn over tenants every couple of years so they can raise rent. Making them feel foolish for charging you so little will only add to the incentive.

If Something Happens, Don't Be Scared

Got a litigious landlord and an ironclad lease? Fear not. When you get served, the papers will be legible and the ideas comprehensible. Read what's actually being charged before you respond or take action. My order had language in it that sought to kick out anyone staying with me, effective immediately. The judge had crossed out this section, presumably until he could hear the case, but I had Airbnb’s staff cancel my remaining reservations anyway, thinking somehow it might help. Due to clerical errors, my case wasn’t heard by a judge until 10 days later, meaning I could have kept my promises to several guests (and kept money coming in) until I figured things out.

Move Slowly

In the blogosphere, news of my eviction has been greatly exaggerated. My restraining order only sought to force me to stop using the service to rent rooms, so if you’re a host, don’t fret you’ll find an eviction notice on your door tomorrow.

If you’ve never been served with court papers, it’s like stepping into your own real-life rage comic—but remember that you can write the ending if you don’t flip out. "Ya know, Christopher, I read your article," were the first words from the opposing counsel during my settlement, as he considered outloud suing me for the $20,000 I said I had made. His heart wasn’t in the threat, and it won’t come to that. But flaming his client on the web, yelling at the building staff, or making threats of my own might have furnished him with more zeal. I spent two absurd, boring days in a courtroom while lawyers scrutinized the language of my Airbnb reviews, and I must say: You do not want to get sucked into all that.

The Landlord Keeps His Property, But You Keep Your Friends

If you live in someone else's building, you may win Airbnb battles, but you will never win the war. Even had I dug into legal action, my lease would still expire naturally in August, and my landlord could choose not to renew it. Lots of friends have reached out to say they’re sorry I’m losing the place—but there are a far-flung handful who I never would have met otherwise.

Read part one of the saga.

[Image: Flickr user: philcampbell]

Add New Comment


  • Michaël Giguère

    Years have passed since that Winter I discovered the AirBnB revolution of happy people sharing homes. I’ve seen hundreds of AirBnB guests, and now, they really sound different, sometimes really annoying, making you feel like your appartment is a Deluxe hotel for 40$/night. Expectations increased for lowered prices, as the platform became really popular. But the whole point of AirbBnB wasn’t business at all. It was meant for home sharing. We may even have contributed to make AirBnB more commercial, as hosts. But popularity killed the simplicity in the end....

    My full story : http://www.michaelgiguere.com/2015/03/never-airbnb-again/

  • Has anyone had any success cutting a profit-sharing deal with a landlord to give him/her an incentive for allowing Airbnb guests? I'm thinking that something like offering a percentage for Airbnb revenue that comes in over a given month's rent might shift a landlord's thinking about this activity.

  • thebiks

    Point One: Landlords don't want guests because of added wear and tear and liability issues. Landlord agrees to rent to you and those stated in the contract, not you and as many people you can rent to. Point Two: Most landlords are not 1%ers.
    Point Three: Most properties have mortgages, all have Real Estate taxes, maintenance and insurance costs that leave many landlords netting very little if anything

  • Hey Chris, Very interesting story and well written. Always good to read stories about real life from real life people. I'm getting a lot of traction with that in the crowdfunding world. Twitter @systemdmfg Fred

  • Nadine Zimmermann

    Im a former Employee of airbnb and I can warn everybody who likes to travel not to usethe serviceof airbnb. I worked in the trust&safety Department of airbnb and checked new listings and hosts on a daily base. The interesting fact I approached there is the low security standards airbnb put on potential new hosts and jeopardize the safety of all guests. If you want to host airbnb guests you can grab any pictures from the internet like a nice five star villa or a beautiful castle and declare yourself as theofficial ownerof this listing, you do not need to provide any form of ID or Proof of Ownership like a Utility bill of the listing. This means in fact that almost more than 50 Percent of the listings on airbnb are fake or put from drug dealers or other criminals to makethe easy money` with the dumb tourists. Trust&Safety just work this way, that they take a look on the Pictures of the listing and declare them as genuine or not. There is no background-check put in place

  • Asheville Jo

    So you were paying almost $3,000 in rent? Hardly destitute...why didn't you just pay a mortgage and "ride the wave" on a board that was yours to ride?? Just curious as to why you seem upset....?

  • Oz

    Hey Anonymous, I'm sure you belong to the 1%, sitting on a large bank account and that makes you feel you can point fingers and judge others. He made his money and there's nothing you can do about it. The main problem with the 1% is that they think they're the only ones entitled to make good money, they want the rest of us to live on minimum salaries and foot stamps. Laws are created with the clear intention to protect the rich.

  • deanmuldrow

    the 1% is too busy working on making more money ---not posting on fast company.com about airbnb rentals.

  • Anonymous

    Wow, you really don't get it do you? You're still outraged, though you clearly violated the terms of your lease. I guess laws really don't apply to you, huh?

  • Stingray Brownell

    Anonymous... you don't know what you're talking about. I host airbnb guests and I have a lease that I am able to respectfully adhere to. Every lease is different. In my situation, guests can not stay any longer than two weeks otherwise I must contact the landlord with their info and they will be considered an additional tennent. Well, my guests never stay past 13 days and I am not in violation. I wouldn't be suprised if my landlord figured out how profitable this is and wants to do it himself, but as long as you operate within the rules of your lease you should legally be fine. Also, I think it is great to draw light on what airbnb does for the host and property. While sites like roomate.com or craigslist will help you find people to fill rooms... airbnb insures your property!!! Any landlord would appreciate that.

  • deanmuldrow

    So your land lord very clearly knows what you are doing.....or you very respectfully rent out your landlords property because their contract is not explicit enough to forbid you renting for profit? Which is it exactly?

  • artzfisher

    Ha! Landlords, i.e. the investment class, want nothing to do with hosting guests. It's a sh**load of work -- younger people don't realize this because they're used to low wages and so it looks like a good deal. Trust me, anybody used to making easy money wants nothing to do with hosting guests every weekend. It takes over most of your available free time, which no landlord except maybe a slum landlord is going to get involved with -- anybody making a living off AirBnB is working plenty hard for that income. I put it at $20/hour when you consider all the hidden hours you have to sit around waiting for people/flakes etc.

  • Julie Rees

    Hi. I have a few questions regarding being an airbnb host. You seem to have some experience. Can I send you a private msg? Thanks, Julie San Clemente, CA